This checklist is designed to help implement the framework in: Lamberg, T. (2013). Whole Class Mathematics Discussions: Improving In-Depth Mathematical Thinking and Learning, Pearson Publishers.  *Can download worksheets from PDToolkit that accompanies book.

Whole-class-mathematics-discussions-Framework-checklist- click here to download

Whole Class Mathematics Discussions: Improving In-Depth Mathematical Thinking and Learning

Framework for Transforming Your Teaching & Implementing the Common Core Standards of Mathematical Practice

The ultimate goal of teaching is to support student LEARNING!


  • What do I want my students to learn?
  • What are they learning?
  • Am I being effective?

 Note: Supporting mathematical learning through whole class discussion involves thinking about the larger picture of planning and teaching. This framework provides a structure for setting up the physical space, planning lessons, developing classroom routines, structuring time and facilitating discussions through Three Levels of Sense Making in order to make mathematical connections.  Optimizing student learning involves situating a whole class discussion within larger mathematical goals. Whole Class discussions should be part of larger conversations that take place over time. The ultimate goal of this framework is to support student achievement in math. Teachers who have used this approach have discovered that student test scores such as state tests and MAP testing scores improved. Practice using this approach over time. It really works!!!! It is not hard to implement. It takes time to make this type of teaching part of your regular teaching routine. Perhaps you are already doing many great things listed in the framework. Fine tuning your teaching makes efficient use of your time to get results!!!

Checklist of Progress: Name: _____________________________________  Date:_________________


Not Met

Work in Progress

Working Great

To do list

Tools from Whole Class Discussion book

Setting up the Classroom





(Chapter 2)

*P.36 Checklist


Setting up Physical Space












Cultivating Classroom Environment/Routines





Note: Routines for (Communicating/Listening

Takes place during whole class discussion. These routines take time to develop.)

(Chapter 3)

*P.60 Strategies for Your Classroom, Ideas for Developing classroom Routines

Routines for Preparing for Discussion





Standards of Mathematical Practice 1,4,5,7,8

Routines for Communicating





Standards of Mathematical Practice 2,3

Routines for Listening/Reflecting





Standards of Mathematical Practice 1







Lesson Planning





Note: Third level of planning takes place during lesson/discussion. The purpose of the first 2 levels of planning is to situate the discussion in larger goals to support deeper learning.

(Chapter 4)

*P.91 Strategies for Your Classroom (Three Levels of Planning)

First level Planning

(Long term & Short Term Goals)

Concepts (big ideas)

Unit Plan (Sequencing/learning trajectory)






*P.92 Concept Map

*P.93 Rubric for Unit Planning

Second Level of Planning

5 E-Lesson Plan- (Anticipating Student Reasoning/Misconceptions Errors,

Format for using a problem solving approach to teaching and structuring time)






*P.94 Rubric for 5E Lesson Plan: Level 2

Third Level of Planning

(Adapting discussion to support student understanding/needs)

Making decisions on what to talk about based on student reasoning during lessons





*Rubric for Planning the Discussion: Level 3


Teacher Questioning/ Supporting Mathematical Connections





Note: These levels of Sense Making make up the Whole discussion. The teacher poses a problem and issue for class to discuss. The teacher uses questions to help students make mathematical connections. Students communicate their ideas; reflect on their own ideas and others being presented to make connections. (See classroom routines section).

  (Chapter 5)

See p. 69

Figure 4.1

(Identify topic for discussion based on goals)

Three Levels of Sense Making





*P.116 Strategies for You Classroom: The Three Levels of Sense Making

Phase 1: Making Thinking explicit





Standards of Mathematical Practice 2, 3, 4

Phase II: Analyzing Each other’s solutions





Helping students make connections from low level strategies to sophisticated strategies See p. 102-103

Address Errors/Misconceptions

Standards of Mathematical Practice 1,3,4,6,7,8

Phase III:  Developing New Mathematical Insights
















See Case Study p.103-107 Identify “big ideas” in Lesson and create a record

Standards of Mathematical Practice 1,2,4,5,6,7,8






Improving Teaching Through Reflection


Reflecting on Your Teaching

(Making Teaching Visible)

(Chapter 6)

What are you currently doing?

What is working/what is not?





Making teaching Visible

What are you currently focusing on?





See: Reflecting on Practice Questions throughout chapters &

*Reflecting on Your Practice Worksheets in End of Chapter Study Guides


Next Steps:


2 responses

  1. […] via WHOLE CLASS DISCUSSION FRAMEWORK – CHECKLIST | Whole Class Mathematics Discussions. […]

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: